The quiet ones are the most dangerous jurors.

Sometimes the most dangerous person in a Massachusetts jury box is the one who tells you the least.

Let's start with a retired bus driver. He looks the part, like one of the older cotton-tops sitting at the corner table at Dunkin' Donuts whom you see every morning on the way to work. Now he's in the jury pool. His questionnaire says "retired bus driver," and during voir dire, he never raises his hand. To the lawyers in the room, he's a blank.

He isn't. For most of his career, he was a physician. Then his wife got cancer, and after years of fighting it with her, he lost her. He left medicine and turned up years later on Cape Cod with his dog, driving a school bus to fill his day. Nobody could have known any of that unless a trained researcher, going through his life online, found it.

Trial lawyers have an old rule: never ask a question you don't already know the answer to. Juror research isn't about finding the answer. It's about knowing which question to ask.

For most of its history, Massachusetts left the questioning of jurors to judges. That began to change with a 2014 law, then a 2015 Superior Court pilot project, then a 2016 statute giving lawyers the right to question prospective jurors in Superior Court.  Superior Court Rule 6 now governs how it works.

But a right to ask isn't the same as time to ask. Rule 6 lets the judge put reasonable limits on the subject, time, and method of lawyer questioning. Supplemental questionnaires often get pruned to the bone, and voir dire can run short. Juror privacy is tight, too.

In the Karen Read case, the judge impounded the jury list. In the Lindsay Clancy trial in Plymouth, prospective jurors were called by panel number in open court, their names known only to the judge, the lawyers, and court staff. If a juror doesn't go on television and expose themselves to the world, their identity and privacy are protected in Massachusetts.

When the clock is that short, you'd better know where to spend it. If a juror's LinkedIn shows a dramatic career change, you ask the whole panel about their work over the past ten years, not just their current job. If a juror is still grieving a death from three years ago, you know how gently to ask about recent losses.

Most jurors who hold back aren't lying. Some don't think an omission counts. Some are private or embarrassed, or think the detail is irrelevant. Some forget, then remember mid-trial, which can mean an appellate issue or a mistrial. And rarely is there a juror lying in wait.

There might be plenty to find online.  Don't believe the stereotype that older people aren't online and that young people know how to hide. Visibility tracks geography more than age. City dwellers tend to lock their profiles down, while in smaller towns social media is how people keep up with family and friends.  And the deeper point is structural: you can lock your own profile, but you can't control what your cousin posts.

Isn't most of it noise? Only if you don't know what you're looking for. Good teams work from a juror risk profile: the experiences and attitudes statistically likely to shape a juror's view of the case. Factors are strongest in combination. Of two jurors identical on paper, the one who is highly religious and does emotionally driven volunteer work may be the riskier pick. Those attitudes affect how willing a juror is to blame and to punish.

Why not let AI do it? It's faster and probably cheaper. But AI risk profiles go stale without constant updating; one built on pre-COVID jury pools knows little about today's. And it won't catch the childhood nickname in a comment that turns out to be the juror's username everywhere, or the cartoon avatar that looks a lot like the juror. An algorithm is only as good as its keywords. Research doesn't replace voir dire. It makes the few minutes a Massachusetts judge spends on voir dire—or the few minutes it gives you—count.

Remember the retired bus driver. He told the court the truth. He just didn't tell the whole story. When a handful of strangers will decide your client's fate, that difference might be the whole game.